Home Transformational Executive Equine Appreciation About Connect
Newsletter Store Login
Header Logo
← Back to all posts

The Fallacies of Pathos

by Federico Malatesta
Mar 13, 2025

 

Fallacies of Pathos are arguments that rely excessively on emotions to persuade the audience, without sufficient supporting evidence or logical reasoning. They exploit our natural emotional responses to manipulate our judgment and sway us towards a certain conclusion, even if the argument itself might be weak or flawed.

One of the earliest categorizations of these fallacies is illustrated in Aristotle's "Rhetoric" (330-322 BC), which distinguished persuasion through logos (logic), ethos (carachter, credibility), and pathos (emotion).

One of the most common modern fallacy of pathos is the "Affective" fallacy (also known as "Follow Your Heart"). The idea underpinning this logical fallacy is that one's feelings and emotions are both innate and self-validating, and thus immune to challenge or criticism.
As we will see on a future essay on the myth of the "Authentic Self" - coming soon! - these ideas, however flawed, remain persistent in the contemporary arena of self-development.

Download Presentation 

 

Reimagine what is next.

Transformational coaching for leaders ready to disrupt their own narrative.

 

www.federicomalatesta.com                                                                 

 

Responses

Join the conversation
t("newsletters.loading")
Loading...
NO, DON'T "LET THEM" - PART II
    This is Part II of my critique of the "Let Them Theory". You can find Part I in the previous post of this Newsletter. Today we widen the lens to interrogate the (very weak) structural foundations of the book and, more in general, expand a number of consideations to the self-help genre. We also sketch an alternative, different path, one that rejects disengagement and dares to embrace the un...
NO, DON'T "LET THEM" - PART I
Over the past few months, Mel Robbins' The Let Them Theory has been inescapable. It drifts through coaching sessions, dominates podcasts, and saturates social media feeds; a neatly packaged promise to deliver peace in two words. Stop resisting. Stop controlling. Stop caring so much about what others do, and you’ll finally be free. But it didn’t take long to sense that beneath the glossy minim...
LEADERSHIP: THE "WHAT" AND THE "HOW"
  Something subtle, but deeply consequential, has happened to the word leadership. In our collective push for emotionally intelligent organizations, we’ve quietly traded the directional power of leadership for its affective shadows. Leadership today is often measured not by where it takes us, but by how it feels to be in the room. Tone has replaced trajectory. This shift isn’t baseless. It’s r...

(almost) Everything is Context

'(almost) Everything is Context' is a space for nuanced conversations on what truly defines a fulfilling life.
© 2025 FM Transformational Coaching™
Footer Logo
Powered by Kajabi

Join Our Free Trial

Get started today before this once in a lifetime opportunity expires.